1-800-MESORAH - 1-800-637-6724

FREE SHIPPING ON ALL ORDERS OVER $49 in the USA

wishlist Earn points 0
Color: Green
personalization: Yes

Purchase the Schottenstein Edition of the Talmud Bavli from ArtScroll. Features include vowelized text, English translation, and comprehensive commentary. Available in various formats to suit your study needs.

Showing 1 - 35 of 51 Results

Order By:

Layout:

Filters

Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Berachos vol. 2 (52b-94b)
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Berachos vol. 2 (52b-94b)
Chapters 5 - 9
Status: Available
Catalog # : YBR2
Release Date : 02/16/2006
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Shevi'is Vol 1 (1a-41b)
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Shevi'is Vol 1 (1a-41b)
Chapters 1 - 5
Status: Available
Catalog # : YSV1
Release Date : 10/04/2006
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition Full Size Set 51 Volumes
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition Full Size Set 51 Volumes
Complete 51 Volume Set
Status: Available
Catalog # : YSHAS
Release Date : 03/06/2022
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
Give the Gift of Eternity. This complete set of the famed Schottenstein edition of the Talmud will be a treasure he will enjoy for many years to come.
List Price:  $2,399.99
Your Price:  $2,159.99
Discount:  10% off

  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Berachos vol. 1(1a-52b)
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#01] - Tractate Berachos vol. 1 (1a-52b)
Chapters 1 - 4
Status: Available
Catalog # : YBR1
Release Date : 11/30/2005
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Peah
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#03] - Tractate Peah
Status: Available
Catalog # : YPEA
Release Date : 06/19/2006
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Demai
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#04] - Tractate Demai
Status: Available
Catalog # : YDEM
Release Date : 01/10/2010
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Kilayim
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#05]- Tractate Kilayim
Status: Available
Catalog # : YKIL
Release Date : 07/27/2009
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Shevi'is Vol 2 (41b-87b)
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#06b] - Tractate Shevi'is Vol. 2 (41b-87b)
Chapters 6 - 10
Status: Available
Catalog # : YSV2
Release Date : 01/03/2007
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Terumos Vol 1 (1a-55a)
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#07] - Tractate Terumos Vol 1 (1a-55a)
Status: Available
Catalog # : YTR1
Release Date : 07/13/2010
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Terumos Volume 2 (55b-107a)
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#08] - Tractate Terumos Vol 2 (55b-107a)
Status: Available
Catalog # : YTR2
Release Date : 10/25/2010
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Maasros
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#09] - Tractate Maasros
Spine vol. #9
Status: Available
Catalog # : YMAA
Release Date : 06/25/2007
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Maaser Sheni
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#10] - Tractate Maaser Sheni
Spine vol. #10
Status: Available
Catalog # : YMSH
Release Date : 05/22/2008
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Challah
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#11] - Tractate Challah
Status: Available
Catalog # : YCHL
Release Date : 12/08/2008
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Orlah / Bikkurim
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#12] - Tractate Orlah / Bikkurim
Status: Available
Catalog # : YORB
Release Date : 12/28/2007
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Shabbos vol. 1 (1a-37b)
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#13] - Tractate Shabbos vol 1 (1a-37b)
Status: Available
Catalog # : YSH1
Release Date : 02/27/2013
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Shabbos vol. 2 (37b-75a)
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#14] - Tractate Shabbos vol 2 (37b-75a)
Status: Available
Catalog # : YSH2
Release Date : 05/20/2013
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Shabbos vol. 3 (75a-113b)
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#15] - Tractate Shabbos vol 3 (75a-113b)
Status: Available
Catalog # : YSH3
Release Date : 10/07/2013
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Eruvin vol. 1 (1a-33a)
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#16] - Tractate Eruvin vol. 1 (1a-33a)
Status: Available
Catalog # : YER1
Release Date : 01/21/2014
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Eruvin vol. 2 (33a-71a)
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#17] - Tractate Eruvin vol. 2 (33a-71a)
Status: Available
Catalog # : YER2
Release Date : 04/02/2014
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Pesachim volume 1(1a-44b)
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#18] - Tractate Pesachim 1(1a-44b)
Status: Available
Catalog # : YPE1
Release Date : 07/26/2011
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Pesachim volume 2 (44b-86a)
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#19] - Tractate Pesachim 2 (44b-86a)
Status: Available
Catalog # : YPE2
Release Date : 01/10/2012
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#20] - Tractate Shekalim
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#20] - Tractate Shekalim
Status: Available
Catalog # : YSHK
Release Date : 11/22/2020
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Yoma
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#21] - Tractate Yoma
Status: Available
Catalog # : YYOMA
Release Date : 03/29/2011
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Succah
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#22] - Tractate Succah
Status: Available
Catalog # : YSU1
Release Date : 08/18/2008
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Beitzah
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#23] - Beitzah
Status: Available
Catalog # : YBEI
Release Date : 03/10/2010
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Taanis
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#25] - Tractate Taanis
Status: Available
Catalog # : YTAA
Release Date : 07/10/2014
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Megillah
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#26] - Tractate Megillah
Status: Available
Catalog # : YMEG
Release Date : 02/27/2012
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Chagigah
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#27] - Tractate Chagigah
Status: Available
Catalog # : YCHG
Release Date : 09/22/2014
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Moed Katan
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#28] - Tractate Moed Katan
Status: Available
Catalog # : YMOK
Release Date : 12/14/2012
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Yevamos 1
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#29] - Tractate Yevamos vol 1
Chapters 1-7
Status: Available
Catalog # : YYE1
Release Date : 03/16/2015
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Yevamos 2
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#30] - Tractate Yevamos vol 2
Chapters 8-16
Status: Available
Catalog # : YYE2
Release Date : 07/14/2015
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Kesubos 1 (1a-40a)
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#31] - Tractate Kesubos vol 1 (1a-40a)
Chapters 1-5
Status: Available
Catalog # : YKE1
Release Date : 10/15/2015
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Kesubos 2 (40a-77b)
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#32] - Tractate Kesubos vol 2 (40a-77b)
Chapters 6-13
Status: Available
Catalog # : YKE2
Release Date : 12/15/2015
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate Nedarim
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#33] - Nedarim
Status: Available
Catalog # : YNED
Release Date : 06/08/2016
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition - Tractate nazir Volume 1 (1a-25a)
Schottenstein Talmud Yerushalmi - English Edition [#34] - Tractate Nazir Vol 1 (1a-25a)
Status: Available
Catalog # : YNA1
Release Date : 09/20/2016
Format : Hardcover
Click here for more information
For five generations of the Talmudic era, the great Sages of the Land of Israel flourished in the Galil. There, like the Sages of Babylonia, they debated, expounded, and applied the laws and principles of the Mishnah that were received at Sinai .The sacre
List Price:  $49.99
Your Price:  $44.99
Discount:  10% off
  
     1  
  • 2
    •    

Shop ArtScroll’s Talmud Bavli Collection

Explore the Depths of the Talmud Bavli with ArtScroll

The Talmud Bavli, or Babylonian Talmud, is a cornerstone of Jewish scholarship, encompassing centuries of rabbinic discussions on Halachah (Jewish law), ethics, philosophy, customs, and history. Its profound insights have guided Jewish thought and practice for generations.

ArtScroll/Mesorah's Schottenstein Edition: A Comprehensive Guide to the Talmud Bavli

ArtScroll/Mesorah is honored to present the Schottenstein Edition of the Talmud Bavli, a monumental work that has made this essential text accessible to scholars and laypeople alike. This edition features:

  • Vowelized and Punctuated Text: The traditional Aramaic and Hebrew text is presented with vowels and punctuation, facilitating accurate reading and comprehension.
  • English Translation and Elucidation: A flowing English translation accompanies the original text, elucidated to clarify complex discussions and concepts.
  • Comprehensive Commentary: Insights from classic commentators, including Rashi and Tosafos, are integrated to enhance understanding.
  • User-Friendly Layout: The format is designed for ease of study, with the original text and translation presented on facing pages.

Available Formats of the Talmud Bavli

To cater to diverse study preferences, the Schottenstein Edition of the Talmud Bavli is available in various formats:

  • Full-Size Edition: Ideal for in-depth study sessions at home or in the Beit Midrash.
  • Daf Yomi Edition: Tailored for participants in the Daf Yomi program, this edition is more compact, facilitating daily study.
  • Travel Edition: A lightweight, paperback version designed for those on the move, ensuring that Torah study can continue uninterrupted during travel.

Digital Access to the Talmud Bavli

Embracing modern technology, ArtScroll/Mesorah offers a digital version of the Talmud Bavli through the ArtScroll Digital Library. This platform provides:

  • Searchable Text: Quickly locate specific discussions or topics within the Talmud.
  • Integrated Audio Shiurim: Enhance your study with synchronized audio lectures.
  • Interactive Features: Bookmarking, note-taking, and other tools to personalize your learning experience.

Purchase the Talmud Bavli Today

Invest in your spiritual and intellectual growth by adding the Schottenstein Edition of the Talmud Bavli to your personal library. Whether you're beginning your journey into Talmud study or seeking to deepen your understanding, ArtScroll/Mesorah's editions are crafted to meet your needs.

Explore our collection and make your purchase today to embark on a transformative learning experience.

Explore More Jewish Books and Resources

Expand your Jewish library with our extensive range of books. Whether you're looking for inspirational reading or educational resources, we have something for everyone. Explore our Jewish Cookbooks for delicious recipes, or deepen your understanding with our Jewish Philosophy Books. Don't miss out on our Siddurim to enhance your daily prayers.

Show More

Loading...
  • Pay at your own pace!
  • With Affirm, split purchases into 4 interest-free payments every two weeks or longer-term monthly payments.
  • When inspiration strikes, Affirm helps you say yes without giving up financial control. Select Affirm to split your purchase into 4 interest-free payments, or select a monthly installment plan over a time period that works best for you.
  • You will be redirected to Affirm's external payment window after reviewing your order on next step.
  • Once your financing is accepted, you will be returned to our site to see the confirmation of your purchase.
  • If one or more items in your order has an extended ship date, your loan payment(s), including interest, may be due before the merchant ships all of the items. Please note that you may not receive a rebate of any interest that may have already accrued on an amount that later gets refunded.